Wailor
Lv.9Design Champion
Comments
Grats, R! Well deserved first place :)
New idea, since the old one was very boring.

Might change the watermark (and replace Recruit with "summon from your deck").
Feedback:
[spoiler text="linkblade91"]I like them a lot. They're a nice twist for the prompt and fit Warlock very well. It's hard to decide between both versions, since the first one has better flavor, but the …
Here's my first take. It's probably too basic, though.


Even if I go with it, I think I'll probably use the same cost & stats as [card]Ramming Mount[/card], since it has better synergy with the effect.
Thanks everyone for your feedback! Especially linkblade, I really liked their suggestion to make the token a buff. I'm still a bit worried about the balance, however...


Feedback:
linkblade91
[spoiler]I'd say I prefer the latter version, but I'm not 100% sure. Both are interesting and flavorful, however.[/spoiler]
R
[spoiler]Simple, yet effective idea. "Lose 1 …


I also made a Druid version, but I didn't upload it to avoid cluttering the page.
I'm quite unsure of which class is better, since death synergy is a Hunter thing, but Armor is a Druid thing.
Will probably tweak the numbers later, since it really gives way too many Armor right now, even if you need …

This looks like the perfect occasion to bring back the Transmute mechanic from my custom Alchemist class.
Main problem here is that I don't know if it is possible to make it so that the drawn cards replace the suffled ones, which is what I intend.
EDIT: Just realized how similar this is to the Tradable keyword. …
Good luck to all finalists. There's a very high level in this one, indeed.
blizz hire me pls
Maiev's skin tone lol That's what zero sun does to a night elf mf
Early feedback:
[spoiler text="Demonxz95"]Applying the Dormant keyword to a weapon is quite smart, honestly, and the "revenant" flavor it has ties well with both Dormant and Deathrattle. My main question is... what would happen if you equip a weapon while this is Dormant? It's gone for good or what?
As for your feedback, my intention was that the …

One question... "Dormant for 1 turn" would be equivalent to "At the beginning of your next turn"? Or would it be the turn after the next one? If it's the latter, then my card is definitely too weak.
Quote From Demonxz95 A mistake I am seeing some people make is including the Legendary gem on the reward (if it isn't a Hero Power). This isn't actually supposed to be there, though I won't be judging harshly on this aspect as it's not really that big of a deal.
Yup, Quest rewards used to …
Improved version of my Quest (mostly aesthetic changes) + a new iteration with a Hero Power reward.




Feedback time:
Hordaki
[spoiler]I feel like the reward isn't too good for the amount of spells you need to cast. I'd either reduce it to 4-5 or improve the damage of the HP to 2.
Otherwise, pretty straightforward …
Quote From linkblade91 Quote From R [spoiler text=linkblade91]Can you imagine warrior without classic spells like [card]Brawl[/card]? This card need a lot of good fire spells to see play.[/spoiler]
I would argue the first part is a lack of imagination, frankly, but yes: the Warrior would need some solid Fire spells for Grimlo to …
Feedback time:
anchorm4n
[spoiler]I personally prefer Acolyte of Frost, even if it should probably be a Legendary, given it introduces of a new mechanic.
Shadowed Reaper is also cool, but it's pretty hard to tell what's going on in the artwork. I'd either zoom in the tauren or use a different art altogether.
Medivh is …
Wow, anchorm4n, I swear I didn't see your cards before making mines, but they both go the same route (even if the execution isn't exactly the same).


EDIT: Changed the cards because previous wording was confusing.
More feedback.
[spoiler text="Lundy"]Thalnos the Soulrender has a nice effect, even if it's a bit too unrelated to the original card for my taste. Besides that, nice card.[/spoiler]
[spoiler text="Me0203"]I feel like all your cards are a bit too crazy, but I'd say I prefer Millhouse, Surge Protector. Most people liked Greenskin, but giving your weapon …
Second iteration of the old man. I only picked 5 mana so that it can maintain [card]Archmage Antonidas[/card]' attack, but you're right that no 5-cost card is barely a limitation. So, here are 3 and 4 mana versions:


The 3-cost version doesn't allow him to be comboed with Secrets or other 3-cost spells (which are quite numerous), while …



