Wailor

Quote From anchorm4n

Update: Added the art and tokens. They don't fit together perfectly, but I probably won't have the time to look for better art this week. Do you think I should use them as they are or just submit the base card? Any flaws detected? 

. . 

I'd say the center of …

Sorry, anchor, I won't submit the Gru card XD Anyways, here are my ideas so far:

Feedback:

Demonxz95

[spoiler]Very neat card. I could see it winning.[/spoiler]

linkblade91

[spoiler]It's a pretty solid concept, but I think she compares too favorably to stuff like [card]The Glass Knight[/card] or [card]C'thun's Chosen[/card]. Not like those cards are any …

Summoning minions, you say? I'm really sorry about this.

Ehem... I'll post something serious tomorrow.

Good luck, guys! I really like all finalists this week :D

Kinda sad my card didn't make it, but it's easy to see why lol

Quote From anchorm4n

Sorry guys and gals, I'm having a nice 60 hours week, fighting covid in a task force at my working place. On top of that, I hardly ever play Battlegrounds. If inspiration strikes tomorrow, I'll slip something in, but that won't be of any quality. I'll participate in the voting, though! 

Keep …

[card]Daring Reporter[/card]

A night elf wearing non-traditional clothes.

Quote From clawz161

Quote From Wailor

I think this prompt is too complicated. There should be more people posting ideas by this point :/ Anyways, I came up with a newer one which is hopefully less broken.

 

Prompt is pretty simple, i thought about making a submission, but i don't really …

I think this prompt is too complicated. There should be more people posting ideas by this point :/ Anyways, I came up with a newer one which is hopefully less broken.

I'll probably scrap both cards, since Radiant First Mate is broken with [card]Goldgrubber[/card] (and [card]Amalgadon[/card], but that card is broken in general and already has [card]Annoy-o-Module[/card], so whatevs) and Shirvallah's Champion is probably a bad idea all around.

Meanwhile, here's some more feedback:

CursedParrot

[spoiler]Unfortunately, that card doesn't work in Constructed, since the concept of "rounds" doesn't …

I've already submited Chromie. I prefered Horrifying Scream, but she had a better reception overall.

More feedback:

DalvanKillder

[spoiler]I prefer Treant'n Treat.

Clever Impersonator is basically a marginally worse [card]Mind Control[/card] for 8 Mana, so it breaks class identity and might be OP.[/spoiler]

AnAngryBadger

[spoiler]I'd try to find another idea. The …

I have two ideas for this so far:

• Radiant First Mate attempts to give a much needed boost to Pirates. Divine Shield has good synergy with Pirates on-attack effects. The fact that she has DS herself makes it so that you can keep her after a couple buffs, unlike the very similar [card]Toxfin[/card]. I'll admit that …

Quote From Wailor

Here are my ideas so far. I'll give feedback later.

Thinking about making Horrifying Scream a Hunter card (depicting Sylvanas instead of a random Banshee) or Chromie a Neutral. It's Alive! is too hard to balance, so I don't think I'll go with it.

 

Bump.

Later came quite soon, actually. Here's my feedback.

@linkblade91

[spoiler]Gravedigger Spade is a bit weird in Hunter. Sure, it can't be a Priest card because it's a weapon and the fact that it only targets Deathrattles kinda fits Hunter, but I still don't see it.

I like Baroness Anastari's concept, but she's very weak right …

Here are my ideas so far. I'll give feedback later.

Thinking about making Horrifying Scream a Hunter card (depicting Sylvanas instead of a random Banshee) or Chromie a Neutral. It's Alive! is too hard to balance, so I don't think I'll go with it.

Maybe it's targeted, dunno.

Some more feedback:

BasilAngus

[spoiler]Very flavorful card. The artwork could be better, though.[/spoiler]

Hordaki

[spoiler]Both are fine. I think I prefer Into the Battlegrounds, just because of the flavor of bringing a different mode to constructed.[/spoiler]

BloodMeFirst

[spoiler]Wrath of the Legion is the best one. The other two are too convoluted to …

Halp! I don't know how to design 10 mana spells that aren't too polarizing :C

• Bastion's effect has been halved, but it's still stronger than [card]Tree of Life[/card] and [card]Nozari[/card] lol. Still, I don't think it's broken compared to [card]Forbidden Healing[/card] (it provides 10 more Health, but it's less flexible).
• Philosopher's Stone is a …

Thanks 😁

Here's my first idea. Not sure if it's too overkill.

I'll give feedback tomorrow. I might post more cards, if I come up with something else.

Thanks everyone for the feedback. I'll end up submitting Sturdy Quarterback, since it's my least controversial card. I'll try to find a better art or at least Photoshop the blood out, and maybe give it a more colorful palette.

More feedback:

Nirast

[spoiler]Undecided Undergrad has amazing flavor. I don't think its complexity should be a …