Making the rest of your deck into big threats that your opponent has to deal with every single turn for the rest of the game is pretty ambitious, especially since I don't recall Warrior having spell tutors.
Siamat for menagerie, but Siamat only really saw play in slower/highlander decks. Not sure if aggressive lower curve menagerie decks will actually want to play this.
If only it said "Increase your max mana and handsize by 1", so that the second copy isn't completely useless. Think it's too ambitious for Combo decks to run just to enable their combo.
The riffs in general makes me feel sad. No Relic Vault or Xy'mox to make them feel good to build around.
Getting two copies of One Amalgam Band is the dream, but could actually just be good as a "draw" card in general for menagerie warrior.
Making the rest of your deck into big threats that your opponent has to deal with every single turn for the rest of the game is pretty ambitious, especially since I don't recall Warrior having spell tutors.
Oh no, lost a draw and got a random card instead!
Anyways...
Siamat for menagerie, but Siamat only really saw play in slower/highlander decks. Not sure if aggressive lower curve menagerie decks will actually want to play this.
Going onto either side of the board is too risky to run in aggro decks. One bad surf chain and suddenly you're behind thanks to your own surfer.
Without class bias in discovers, you're just as likely to hit the weaker neutrals rather than your class's powerhouses.
Would.
...
Oh you mean in a deck, absolutely not.
4 attack is very significant, pushes a lot of damage and at 5 health, people are more likely to kill the buff target instead.
Pretty much the entire reason why people are even considering building around menagerie.
Really good on curve, absolute must include in menagerie builds, just solid overall.
Good with handbuffs, though I'm not entirely sure there's a good deck in there...
Lucio is in the HOUSE!!! Just a decent rush minion even without the finale, slower decks will appreciate the healing and early trading this offers.
Think this is the 29th/30th cards in menagerie, literally just running it for the totem tag. Single target handbuffs rarely get there.
If only it said "Increase your max mana and handsize by 1", so that the second copy isn't completely useless. Think it's too ambitious for Combo decks to run just to enable their combo.
Rogue is probably the only candidate that could make this good... but I don't think it'd be a good Rogue deck.
Faceless for the next generation.
Lots of whiffs and so few great hits.
Probably the other big target Paladin wants to pull with their Big package, and can be a board clear by itself. Probably doesn't survive the turn tho.
Awful effect, only just above average on your next turn, and only gets worse from there.